Skip to main content

Understanding Q3FY22 Results - Earnings growth narrows

After a broad-based earnings bounce back in FY21, growth narrowed sharply in FY22. 

Key highlights: 

1. Top line recovery is moderate at 12% YoY and is largely led by prices, while volumes have been weak. 

2. Margin pressure due to higher input prices. Resulting in corporates pruning fixed costs again – wage bill growth for BSE500 (ex IT) has slowed to 7% YoY – pre-COVID low. 

3.Banking sector’s asset quality continues to improve as MSMEs bounce back; although not out of the woods yet. 

Way forward: 

Going ahead, there are risks arising out of earnings downgrades (after upgrades in the last two years) as earnings become increasingly demand dependent (as opposed to being cost and price dependent until now) – which is weak and outlook uncertain. This, along with high valuations, and tightening global liquidity warrants a decisive pivot towards low beta (risk) 


Q3FY22 earnings: Demand revival slow, margin pressures high

Revenue: Topline increased 26%YoY (Q2FY22: 32% YoY). This is mainly aided by commodities. Excluding it, the revival remains weak at 12% YoY (Q2FY22: 16% YoY) with domestic sectors more subdued.

Profit: The skew in profits is even higher. While coverage universe posted strong 21% YoY growth, it's heavily concentrated in commodities and banks. Excluding them, it has slipped into contraction.


Sectoral trends: In retrospect and prospects

Domestic consumption: EBITDA saw a sharp and broad-based moderation. The tide has turned quite adverse for durables (ex-autos), which saw large margin pressures and moderating volume growth, domestic autos remains weak but consumer services (hotels, retail) continued its recovery. Consensus is forecasting a very strong FY23, which could disappoint.

Domestic investment: In Q3FY22, cement companies posted sharp moderation in EBITDA/ton as input prices hurt. Industrial companies on the other hand reported better top line and margin performance as government capex improved.

Global exporters: IT companies reported strong top lines and deal-wins, but margins moderated. Chip shortage weighed on export auto, while pharma was a mixed bag. Chemical companies too disappointed on the margins front as they saw a moderation. Going ahead, growth momentum in IT should continue, but China slowdown could weigh on auto export and chemical companies.

Commodities: OMCs disappointed on marketing margins (inventory loss), while upstream energy companies posted strong results. Metal companies’ profits though strong YoY are now moderating. Unwinding global reflation to weigh on commodity profits.

Financials: Slippages continue to moderate and credit costs have eased. However, incrementally credit growth revival is critical to support earnings recovery as credit costs have normalized and banks are now tracking credit growth (after growing much higher in FY21).



Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Insight from the new book "The story of work" by Jan Lucassen. Work that never ends

The more things change, its turn out to be the  same as it ever was.  A new book about the history of work reveals that today’s workers have much in common with all those who have come before them over the past 12,000 years.  People’s appetites drive them to produce more than they need, and they build political and economic institutions to help them do it. Then those institutions drive them to do more. NYT ( see the story in the link)  also talks about  Gluttons for punishment.  We work so much because we want so much. That was anthropologist James Suzman’s conclusion after studying hunter-gatherers in the Kalahari Desert who satisfied their survival needs with roughly 15 hours of weekly labor. But modern, urban societies cause us to develop unlimited desires, which lead us to endless labour https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/29/podcasts/transcript-ezra-klein-interviews-james-suzman.html?cid=other-eml-onp-mip-mck&hlkid=38845d000b404e829c41b7395739f39a&...
Post a Comment
Read more

Hedge Funds: Shape up or ship out

With markets testing their mettle, the new mantra for hedge funds is ‘perform or pay back’! - a la shapeup or ship out. Hedge funds that enjoyed a one-sided bargain with their clients in reaping handsome fees now need to pull up their socks. For if they don’t, they will be losing some of their biggest clients. As per Wall Street Journal, the California Public Employees' Retirement System, popularly known as Calpers, that is one of the biggest investors in hedge funds, is demanding better terms from funds. This includes lower fees and claw-back of fees if performance weakens. For the uninitiated, the US$ 172 bn pension fund is a bellwether in the money-management business. A Calpers investment can in fact help money managers like hedge funds attract other clients. This move by Calpers therefore underscores the changing dynamics between hedge funds and their clients. Just a couple of years ago, investors clamored to get an entry into these funds, agreeing to pay fees that in some cas...
Post a Comment
Read more

Biyani looks at the bigger picture

It is important to look at the holistic picture and have an individual opinion rather than get swayed away by the public consensus. This is the view of the man who pioneered the retailing boom in India - Mr. Kishore Biyani, the founder of India’s largest retailing company - Pantaloon. In an article in the Wall street Journal, Mr. Biyani wrote, "Almost daily doses of bad news on television screens and newspapers have possibly done as much damage to the economy as the events on either side of the Atlantic." I completely agree with him. Mr. Biyani’s predicament is based on the fact that an overwhelming majority of Indian consumers are self-employed, who can neither get laid off nor can have pay cuts. Consider some statistics he has provided. The share of the national income represented by proprietor-run concerns and partnerships is 35%. The share of companies is around 15%, government around 25%, and agriculture around 25%. Combine agriculture and the self-employed in industry a...
1 comment
Read more